As a firm that represents both employers and employees, frustration is growing among the latter. Employees (largely the ones that pushed against the vaccination altogether) are complaining about being forced to vaccinate to hold on to their jobs and helping the employer manage vaccination passports from an operational standpoint.
Suffice to say, a large number of employees tell us these changes have resulted in over-all demoralization in the workplace. Employees ask us repeatedly: “Do we have to act as frontline staff for our employer? It was never part of our job description.” A client recently complained by stating, “I am a server, but I did not sign up to act as security at the door. I am scared of confrontation, why do I have to do this? I don’t fully understand who qualifies for an exemption.”
A growing number of employees do not want to risk involvement in a potential confrontation while trying to determine who should be allowed into a business.
In a perfect world, employers would hire staff tasked specifically to deal with vaccine passports at the door. But the pandemic world is far from perfect.
Employers cannot ignore the fact that some patrons, clients and customers will do the following:
1. Try to gain entry into their business unvaccinated by claiming that they have a medical or religious exemption (as it stands, Ontario has not yet followed suit with Quebec, which has banned all religious considerations in the face of what it calls a “public health urgency”); and
2. Present falsified vaccination documents to gain entry into their business.
Recently, Muneeza attended a dinner at a well-known Toronto steakhouse only to see that the patron ahead of her did not have ID to prove their vaccine conformation. The flustered waiter considered denying entry and potentially causing a scene. In the end, he did not. Later when asked why he did not turn the patron away. He responded by saying, “they don’t pay me enough to do this. It is stressful, and I operate largely on tips. They should hire someone to do this work.”
The answer made sense, but if the restaurant was strict about the vaccine passport implementation, this employee could have been terminated for cause in our view for violating the rules of the restaurant and province.
From an employee’s perspective they neither have the skills, training, or expertise to properly make a determination about whether a human rights exemption (medical or religious) is valid. While the government has provided some guidance on medical exemptions, there are a slew of accompanying conditions and, of course, a narrative around those conditions not easily decipherable for most. Establishing whether a doctor’s note is sufficient before medical exemptions can be integrated into a vaccine certificate is not easy.
Even if the unvaccinated employees make it into the business, there is still the issue of having them wear masks and maintain social distancing. While the liability falls on the employer, the strict adherence of the policy falls on the shoulders of its employees.
Furthermore, the provincial mothership has stated that employers, in implementing vaccine passports, should not hesitate to get law enforcement involved. While this provides reassurance and support to employers, it has created significant anxiety for employees refusing to partake in a potential door place scuffle.
So, do your job duties include helping your employer maintain a safe working environment in relation to the vaccination passport?
The short answer: yes.
Generally, most Canadian employees must assist their employer in keeping the workplace safe. This includes ensuring that those who enter are vaccinated and not lying about it.
What if the new duties fall outside of your original job?
If, as part of your general duties, you are responsible for ensuring the business runs smoothly, then this new task as frontline security is not a significant change to your job duties. Put another way, if overseeing the business is what you do – then consider this to be an expansion of that obligation.
In our view, there are few employees that could argue that the new duties around implementation of vaccine passports fall far outside of the scope of their job. If you are the company bookkeeper, rarely interacting with clients/patrons/customers, you may be able to argue that you are being forced to do a brand-new job. The employee in this unique scenario might be able to push back and punt the duties to employees better suited to do the work.
As an employer, you can do the following to ensure that your employees are not left overburdened and anxious:
In our view, there are few employees that could argue that the new duties around implementation of vaccine passports fall far outside of the scope of their job. If you are the company bookkeeper, rarely interacting with clients/patrons/customers, you may be able to argue that you are being forced to do a brand-new job. The employee in this unique scenario might be able to push back and punt the duties to employees better suited to do the work.
As an employer, you can do the following to ensure that your employees are not left overburdened and anxious:
